thefangirlslayer:
returnoftheperv:
thefangirlslayer:
I will maintain forever and always that Buffy getting kicked out of her house in season 7 was needed for her character. She needed to be brought back down to Earth and stop with the fucking power trip. She needed to realize that lashing out, barking orders, not listening to other points of view is…
What other points of view? You know she did listen to another point of view—Wood’s, who encouraged her to test the girls even though she herself felt they weren’t ready—and bad things happened. She didn’t follow her instincts and others paid the price. She knew something was hidden at the vineyard and wanted to discuss a strategy to go back in. That’s right, discuss.
As for the rest of them, what did they do? They immediately shut down ALL other points of view, namely from Kennedy, in order to follow the cowardly and stupid plan that got girls killed. The Scoobies were not interested in democracy. They were afraid. It really was that simple. They didn’t trust her because they never trusted her. The times they didn’t believe in her are legion, about Kathy, about Angelus, rescuing Dawn, about Jonathon and on and on.
For the ranking S7 gets for lack of direction, it’s funny that probably the most anvil-esque metaphor, that the First Evil represents self-doubt, is completely ignored.
It was totally her idea to go into the barn when Caleb came to town. Despite everyone telling her, including Spike, that it screams trap and looked what happened? Lets not forget that Buffy had been known for her rash run in guns a blazing approach that put them in danger. Like in Season 2 when she ran to go fight Angelus meanwhile her friends are attacked and Kendra got killed. Everyone told her it was a trap then, but she didn’t listen.
“They didn’t trust her because they never trusted her. The times they didn’t believe in her are legion, about Kathy, about Angelus, rescuing Dawn, about Jonathon and on and on.” Not trusting and not believing are two COMPLETELY different things. They did trust her, but that doesn’t mean that she didn’t make mistakes and that she didn’t go around acting like she was some sort of God who thought she was better than everyone, giving the “everyone sucks but me” speech.
My point was that her getting kicked out caused her to realize that sharing power is important, which is exactly what happens in the end.
First off, wasn’t a barn. Second, they went and scouted it out, saw nothing that would indicate a problem. She goes to Wood, tells him she does not think the girls are ready for a mission. She doubts herself, takes them anyway, bad things happened. You do remember what happened the first time she ran off? It was to keep her friends out of danger. It’s a no-win situation. In the end, who was proven to be right? Having Buffy be proven correct sort of shows the writers’ cards where intent is concerned.
No, they did NOT trust her. No, they were not different things. They were, in fact, the same things. Her friends never backed her up as a leader; they always deferred to Giles, just like they did in this instance. Just as Faith did after they kicked Buffy out. Faith and Giles shutting down Kennedy and any form of dissent, was that their god complexes showing? Let’s see, one person who is willing to discuss a strategy in a dangerous plan vs. two leaders who won’t listen to anyone in a stupid plan? Yeah, it was person A who was the intransigent one.
Buffy had a god complex and thought she knew everything? Ah, I see you rarely paid attention to the instances in CWDP, Showtime, GiD, Storyteller, Dirty Girls and others where she outright admitted to not knowing everything and thinking her friends were better than her and doubted her abilities? Where the First used those very words to cast doubt into the minds of the Potentials and Chloe, causing her to off herself? Yeah, Buffy had a real high opinion of herself. And of course she’s a horrible bitch for calling out Spike, who embarrassed her by getting up and walking out while she was talking in plain view of everyone, or Willow for resting on her magical laurels. If anyone else gives that speech, fandom would have been creaming their pants over it. When Buffy has something to say, it has to be coated in please and thank you and sprinkled with sugar. All the gang sitting around doing nothing while their ‘friend’ is burying the body of a 15 yr old. Piss on that, they deserved every word of it.
S7 and Buffy sharing her power was about seeing it not as a burden, but as a strength. Willow, Spike and Buffy all go through the season being afraid of their power, thinking it made them lesser and in the end grew to see it as a strength and used that strength to free all the girls being hunted down by the First. The very thing that chained Buffy and Faith and all the other slayers down was used to set all the Potentials free.